[This piece
is] a kind of reconciliation of these two musical
languages, of a more tonal language, and my early atonal
language….It’s almost as if I’m talking
about the destruction of tonality. It begins with an
idiom that very much resembles the early idiom. Then it
goes into a more Purcellian kind of thing, modified of
course, and it ends with an epilogue.
The first song is an
“Ode to Orpheus,” by Rilke, in which
Orpheus’s music calms the animals and they come to
listen to him. Then there is a “Purcellian Air on a
Ground.” Then “Pied Beauty,” a great
poem by Gerard Manley Hopkins….After that there
comes another “Air on a Ground.” Then
there’s the second “Sonnet to Orpheus”
in which Orpheus is torn apart, literally physically torn
apart, by the Maenads, they destroy him. It’s as
if—it wasn’t clear to me until the work was
over—it’s as if the music is describing what
happened to tonality—it became this destroyed
thing.
The next part is a setting
of “Henry Purcell” by Gerard Manley Hopkins,
“Have, fair fallen, O fair, fair have fallen, so
dear to me, so arch-especial a spirit as heaves in Henry
Purcell,” Then, “Not mood in him nor meaning,
proud fire or sacred fear, Or love, or pity, or all that
sweet notes not his might nursle: It is the forgèd
feature finds me.” And it ends with an epilogue in
which Rilke says, “even in destructiveness a poet
can make a world.” There’s some connection
there about something being destroyed, and making another
world out of it.
As in many things that I
do, it wasn’t a conscious attempt, but in looking
back, this is what happened. You’ll hear it
musically—you’ll hear the two kinds of music
that I’m working with.
–Vivian Fine, speaking at Harvard,
April 20, 1989
Fine wrote
counterpoint with long phrases for “Sonnet to
Orpheus.” Frequently each member of the string
quartet functions as a singer, having phrase lengths and
rhythmic patterns similar to fine’s vocal
realization of the poertry….one interesting use of
kaleidoscoping is in the first “sonnet to
Orpheus.” The text is about listening as a
spiritual tool for understanding, and for the the closing
passage “und wo eben kaum eine Hutte war, dies zu
empfangen” (“And where before there was
hardly a shed where this listening could go”), Fine
recapitualated the string quartet’s lines by
superimposing phrases from differing parts of the
sonnet.
“Pied Beauty”
begins with a vocal solo, “Glory be to God for
dappled things.” Fine reflects this dappling and
Hopkin’s creative use of language in the string
quartet’s accompaniment to the voice. She composed
a four-measure ostinato of sextuplets and a quintuplet
for the first violin, which is so variegated it is
impossible to find a pattern for the multitude of pitch
choices and the subtle phrasing in groups of 12, 6, 9, 7,
and so on. The second violin’s countermelody is
formed from pitches at the end of each sextuplet. In
prevous compositions when Fine wanted such a texture,she
would use a rotational pitch system, retrogrades, and
canons, as in Missa Brevis. Such is not the case with
“Pied Beauty.” When the ostinato is repeated,
it is moved to another voice and thickened by having an
additional voice move at a third below and then in the
next cycle by having voices a third above and below. The
texture is further variegated by having a slower
countermelody shift so that it outlines other pitches
from the active texture.
In the third song of the
cycle, a second “Sonnet to Orpheus,” Fine has
the quartet’s material provide unity and contrast.
Its energetic four-measure phrase announces and
influences the soprano’s beginning solo passage.
Later the quartet’s phrase returns trilled and
elongated….A pizzicato ostinato texture somewht
reminscent of “Pied Beauty” becomes the
setting for a new section, which is a mixture of
sprechstimme and normal singing….
The last song, “Henry
Purcell” is simpler, with the melodic praises to
Purcell embroidered upon the repeating Ground. A vocal
quote from the first “Sonnet to Orpheus ends
“Henry Purcell” and leads to the epilogue,
which repeats the ostinato from Hopkin’s
“Pied Beauty” but with new melody and text by
Rilke place above.
–Heidi Von Gunden,
The Music of Vivian Fine, Scarecrow Press,
1999